Will HMRC Publish My Name? The New Deliberate Defaulter Rules

HMRC can publish your name, address and business details if it finds that you incurred a penalty for deliberate conduct and the tax lost exceeds £50,000. That threshold doubled from £25,000 on 2 October 2026. You stay off the list if HMRC reduced your penalty by the maximum the law allows for disclosure, and Finance Bill 2026-27 would let HMRC name company directors who are made to pay part of the company’s penalty.

Most people who ask us this have just received a letter saying HMRC considers their behaviour deliberate, or have been told during a Code of Practice 9 investigation that publication is possible. What surprises them is that the outcome depends less on the size of the bill than on two things they can still influence: how HMRC labels the behaviour, and how complete their disclosure is.

Want legal advice from Tax Solicitors on your case?

Our simple enquiry form goes immediately to our tax litigators in Middle Temple, London. Call us on +442071830529 from 9am-6pm.

What section 94 allows HMRC to publish

The power sits in section 94 Finance Act 2009. Section 94(1) provides that “The Commissioners may publish information about any person if” two conditions are met: that “in consequence of an investigation conducted by the Commissioners, one or more relevant tax penalties is found to have been incurred by the person”, and that the potential lost revenue “exceeds £50,000”. The word “person” covers individuals, companies and partnerships, and our page on HMRC penalties explains the penalty regimes the section draws on.

Section 94(4) sets out what may be published: the person’s name “(including any trading name, previous name or pseudonym)”, their address or registered office, the nature of any business, the amount of the penalty and the potential lost revenue, the periods concerned, and anything else HMRC considers appropriate “in order to make clear the person’s identity”. Under section 94(5) HMRC may publish “in any manner that the Commissioners consider appropriate”, and in practice the list appears on GOV.UK where lenders, customers and the press can read it. Our guidance on HMRC tax investigations and penalties covers the earlier stages.

The £50,000 threshold and how HMRC counts it

The Finance Act 2009 (Publishing Details of Deliberate Tax Defaulters: Increase to Threshold) Order 2026, SI 2026/1000, substituted “£50,000” for “£25,000” in section 94(1)(b) with effect from 2 October 2026. HMRC’s policy paper says the higher figure applies from its November 2026 publication list and expects about 800 individuals and businesses a year to be affected. Our page on HMRC tax investigations describes the enquiries behind these penalties.

The figure is potential lost revenue, which section 94(3) defines by reference to paragraphs 5 to 8 of Schedule 24 Finance Act 2007 and paragraphs 7 to 11 of Schedule 41 Finance Act 2008. Broadly, it is the extra tax that becomes due once the inaccuracy is corrected. Section 94(1)(b) also aggregates, so the test is whether “the aggregate of the potential lost revenue in relation to each of the penalties” exceeds £50,000. Several modest deliberate errors across different years can cross the line together, and HMRC usually reaches earlier years through HMRC discovery assessments.

Which penalties put you at risk?

Section 94(2) confines publication to a “relevant tax penalty”. That means a penalty under paragraph 1 of Schedule 24 FA 2007 “in respect of a deliberate inaccuracy”, a paragraph 1A penalty for deliberately supplying false information or withholding information, a penalty under paragraph 1 of Schedule 41 FA 2008 “in respect of a deliberate failure” to notify, and the Schedule 41 penalties for unauthorised VAT invoices and excise wrongdoing. A careless penalty never qualifies, whatever its size, which is why our tax penalty appeals work so often turns on the behaviour finding.

Paragraph 3(1) of Schedule 24 separates “careless”, meaning a “failure by P to take reasonable care”, from “deliberate but not concealed” and “deliberate and concealed”. For a domestic inaccuracy, paragraph 4(2) sets the penalty at 70% of the potential lost revenue for deliberate but not concealed action and 100% where it is concealed. The test asks about conduct “on P’s part”, so an accountant’s mistake you knew nothing about is evidence against a deliberate finding and may support a claim against the accountant, as our guide on claims where an accountant failed to warn about a tax liability explains. We cover how HMRC builds a deliberate case in our guide to HMRC behaviour assessments.

The disclosure exemption in section 94(10)

Section 94(10) provides that “No information may be published if the amount of the penalty is reduced under” paragraph 10 of Schedule 24, or paragraph 13 of Schedule 41, “to the full extent permitted”. Paragraph 10(1) requires HMRC to reduce the penalty to one “that reflects the quality of the disclosure”, down to a floor. For a deliberate but not concealed inaccuracy the floor is 35% after a prompted disclosure and 20% after an unprompted one; for deliberate and concealed behaviour it is 50% and 30%. Our 2026 guide to voluntary disclosure covers how those reductions are earned.

Disclosure has a statutory meaning. Paragraph 9(1) of Schedule 24 requires “telling HMRC about it”, “giving HMRC reasonable help in quantifying the inaccuracy” and “allowing HMRC access to records”. Paragraph 9(3) adds that quality “includes timing, nature and extent”. A late or partial disclosure leaves some of the reduction unearned, and falling short of the maximum by any margin brings you back within section 94. Our article on voluntary disclosure for avoiding prosecution deals with the criminal side of the same decision.

Prompted disclosure can still keep you off the list

Many guides say only an unprompted disclosure protects you. For domestic matters the statute says otherwise. Section 94(10)(a) refers to paragraph 10 of Schedule 24 without any qualification, so a prompted disclosure that earns the full reduction down to the prompted minimum keeps you off the list. The word “unprompted” appears only in section 94(10)(aa) and (c), which deal with offshore matters under paragraph 10A of Schedule 24 and paragraph 13A of Schedule 41. Our 2026 guide to responding to COP8 and COP9 investigations shows how that plays out once HMRC has made contact.

The first weeks of an enquiry therefore carry real weight. Someone who receives an opening letter and then cooperates fully can still reach the floor; someone who delays usually cannot. Our article on what to do if you receive an HMRC letter of enquiry covers those early decisions.

When publication can start, and when it must stop

Three time rules apply. Under section 94(7), nothing may be published “before the day when the penalty becomes final”. Under section 94(8), nothing may be published for the first time once a year has passed from that day. Under section 94(9), nothing may be published or “continue to be published” more than a year after it first appeared. Our page on the First Tier Tax Tribunal explains the appeal process.

Section 94(11) fixes when a penalty becomes final. For an assessed penalty it is “when the time for any appeal or further appeal relating to it expires or, if later, any appeal or final appeal relating to it is finally determined”. Where the case is settled by contract with HMRC, it is “at the time when the contract is made”, which matters in Code of Practice 9 cases. A live appeal therefore holds publication back until it is decided.

Directors and the proposed section 94A

Clause 228 of Finance Bill 2026-27, introduced on 4 November 2026, would insert a new section 94A into the Finance Act 2009. HMRC could then publish details of a company officer where the company itself has been published under section 94, the officer “has been given a notice under paragraph 19 of Schedule 24 to FA 2007 or paragraph 22 of Schedule 41 to FA 2008”, and the officer’s share “exceeds £25,000”. Paragraph 19 already lets HMRC make an officer pay “such portion of the penalty (which may be 100%)” where a company’s deliberate inaccuracy “was attributable to an officer”. Directors also facing insolvency should see our guide to director liability after a winding up petition.

The published details would include the officer’s name, address, “position (or former position) in the company”, the company’s name and “the portion of the penalty or penalties which the officer is liable to pay”. The same clause would change section 94(4), replacing the penalty amount and potential lost revenue with “details of the inaccuracy, failure or action” and “details of the penalty or penalties”. Clause 228(3) applies all of this only “where the conduct or failure giving rise to the penalty (or each of the penalties) occurred on or after the day on which this Act is passed”, and the Bill can still be amended. HMRC already has a separate power to name sanctioned tax advisers, which we cover in our guide to HMRC’s new sanctionable conduct powers over tax advisers.

Two different notices called personal liability notices

Searches for “personal liability notice” mix up two separate regimes. The better known is the notice under section 121C Social Security Administration Act 1992, which applies where a company’s unpaid National Insurance “appears to the Inland Revenue to be attributable to fraud or neglect” by its officers. That is the notice covered in our 2026 guide to personal liability notices for directors and our page on personal liability notice appeals and enforcement. The other is the officer’s notice under paragraph 19 of Schedule 24, or paragraph 22 of Schedule 41, which passes on part of a deliberate behaviour penalty.

On the Bill’s wording, proposed section 94A reaches only the second kind, even though HMRC’s policy paper describes the change as allowing it to publish “details of Personal Liability Notices”. A director holding a section 121C notice for unpaid National Insurance is outside it. The defences to each notice differ, and we set them out in our defence strategies for directors facing PLNs. Being named is also separate from disqualification under the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986, which our guide to directors’ disqualification proceedings covers.

Can you stop HMRC naming you?

Section 94(6) requires HMRC, before publishing, to “inform the person that they are considering doing so” and to “afford the person reasonable opportunity to make representations about whether it should be published”. HMRC’s policy paper says it will not publish where there is a risk to safety or exceptional reasons not to, and that it may limit the detail it publishes. Representations work best with medical, safety or commercial evidence attached, and our HMRC tax investigation and penalty advice includes preparing them.

Section 94 gives no right of appeal against the publication decision itself. The usual challenge is to the penalty, by appealing under paragraph 15 of Schedule 24 against a decision “that a penalty is payable” or “as to the amount”, on the basis that the behaviour was careless or that the disclosure reduction should have been the maximum. Paragraph 17(2) lets the tribunal “substitute for HMRC’s decision another decision that HMRC had power to make”, and the appeal can begin with an HMRC internal review. Where HMRC reaches a publication decision unlawfully, judicial review remains, as our page on judicial review applications against HMRC explains.

Offshore cases and people who control a company

Section 94(4A) to (4D) go further where the inaccuracy or failure “involves an offshore matter or an offshore transfer”. If a company or partnership incurs such a penalty, HMRC may also publish details of any individual who “controls the body corporate or the partnership (within the meaning of section 1124 of CTA 2010)” and “has obtained a tax advantage as a result of the inaccuracy or failure”. Section 94(4D) covers individual trustees in the same way, and our page on offshore tax evasion explains the wider regime.

Offshore cases also lose the prompted disclosure route. Section 94(10)(aa) protects only a reduction under paragraph 10A “to the full extent permitted following an unprompted disclosure”, and paragraph 9(1B) of Schedule 24 adds a fourth requirement of “providing HMRC with additional information”. Anyone with undeclared overseas income should read our page on HMRC voluntary disclosure campaigns before HMRC writes to them first.

The deadline that decides your position

The governing deadline is the one for appealing the penalty. Paragraph 16(1) of Schedule 24 provides that a penalty appeal “shall be treated in the same way as an appeal against an assessment to the tax concerned”. For income tax, section 31A(1) Taxes Management Act 1970 requires written notice “within 30 days after the specified date”, which for an assessment is the date the notice was issued. When that period passes without an appeal, the penalty becomes final under section 94(11)(a), and HMRC’s one-year window to publish opens. Our page on late appeals to the tax tribunal explains what happens if the date has already gone.

A late appeal needs HMRC’s agreement or the tribunal’s permission, and neither is guaranteed. If you have a penalty letter, a warning about publication or an opening COP9 letter, work from the date printed on it, and read our guide on whether it is too late to appeal against HMRC if you think you have missed it.

How We Can Help

We act for individuals, companies and directors facing deliberate behaviour penalties, Code of Practice 9 investigations and HMRC proposals to publish their details. We challenge behaviour findings, negotiate disclosure reductions, draft representations against publication and run appeals, as described on our tax penalty appeals page. We do not offer free legal advice or legal aid, and we generally take on substantial matters, including the HMRC tax investigations where publication is most likely.

We are dual qualified solicitors and barristers with chambers in Middle Temple, next to the Royal Courts of Justice. We offer a fixed fee advice conference with both a solicitor and a barrister, and you can start by completing our legal case assessment form.

Want legal advice from Tax Solicitors on your case?

Our simple enquiry form goes immediately to our tax litigators in Middle Temple, London. Call us on +442071830529 from 9am-6pm.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will HMRC publish my name for a careless error?

No. Section 94(2) Finance Act 2009 limits publication to penalties for deliberate inaccuracies, deliberate failures to notify and certain deliberate wrongdoing. A careless inaccuracy penalty under Schedule 24 Finance Act 2007 is not a relevant tax penalty, however much tax is involved.

What is the current threshold for HMRC’s deliberate defaulters list?

Potential lost revenue must exceed £50,000 under section 94(1)(b) Finance Act 2009. The figure was raised from £25,000 by SI 2026/1000 with effect from 2 October 2026. Where there are several penalties, their potential lost revenue is added together.

Does a prompted disclosure stop HMRC publishing my details?

For a domestic matter it can. Section 94(10)(a) bars publication where the penalty is reduced under paragraph 10 of Schedule 24 to the full extent permitted, and that includes the prompted minimum. For an offshore matter, section 94(10)(aa) requires the full reduction following an unprompted disclosure.

How long will my name stay on the published list?

Section 94(9) Finance Act 2009 stops publication one year after the information first appears. Section 94(8) also requires HMRC to publish for the first time within one year of the day the penalty becomes final, so HMRC cannot hold a case back indefinitely.

This article is general information about the law of England and Wales as at 20 November 2026 and is not legal advice. Take advice on your own circumstances before acting.

search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close