HMRC has now collected more than £8m from crypto investors who came forward voluntarily to put their tax right, having first sent around 100,000 warning letters. The numbers are modest next to the size of the market, which tells us the pressure on unreported crypto gains is only beginning.
Figures released under the Freedom of Information Act show that 502 investors made disclosures to HMRC’s crypto route in its first two years, and that £8,328,132 was recovered in total. For anyone who has sold, swapped or spent crypto without reporting it, the question is no longer whether HMRC is paying attention, but how to deal with the position on the best possible terms. This article explains what the figures show, the three ways a crypto tax problem can be resolved, and how early advice on an HMRC tax investigation can change the outcome.
HMRC TAX DISPUTES LEGAL ADVICE & DEFENCE
Our lawyers have a track record of successfully challenging HMRC decisions and will assist you to get an optimal result. We analyse the merits at the very outset in an initial video conference together with leading (ex-HMRC and Big 4) tax litigation counsel. We provide urgent advice and representation to clients from our unique expert team of established Tax specialist solicitors and barristers with a proven track record of delivering results. Call us on +442071830529, or email contact@lexlaw.co.uk.
What Do HMRC’s Crypto Disclosure Figures Show?
The route opened in November 2023 for people who had not paid tax on exchange tokens, NFTs and similar assets. According to the FOI figures, 280 people made disclosures in 2024/25, paying £3,543,387. In 2025/26, 222 people came forward and £4,784,745 was recovered. Fewer people paid more: the average settlement rose from about £12,700 to about £21,600. HMRC has said that disclosure is only one of the tools it uses, alongside enquiries, data analysis and targeted interventions.
Two cautions apply. First, earlier published figures for the same service differ in their numbers and periods, so the totals are best read as a guide to scale and direction rather than as exact statistics. Second, the figures cover only those who used this particular route. Crypto cases are also being resolved through ordinary enquiries and through the more serious civil investigation procedures. The real volume of HMRC activity is therefore higher than the headline suggests.
The more telling number is the volume of letters. HMRC has reportedly sent around 100,000 so-called nudge letters to suspected non-compliant investors over the last few years. A nudge letter is not an accusation, and it is not yet an enquiry, but it tells you that HMRC holds data about you and expects you to check your returns.
How Does HMRC Know About Your Crypto?
HMRC does not rely on investors volunteering information. It has formally requested customer records from UK exchanges and uses the data to compare what individuals did with what they reported. The UK is also introducing the Cryptoasset Reporting Framework, an international system under which crypto service providers will report user and transaction data to tax authorities. The UK rules were due to start from 1 January 2026, and HMRC’s current guidance for providers confirms that reporting is coming, although it no longer gives a firm date for the first reports while the online reporting service is finalised.
In practical terms, an investor who has been using a UK or overseas exchange should assume that the activity can be seen, and that the visibility will increase.
Which Crypto Transactions Create a Tax Charge?
Most individuals hold crypto as an investment, which means that Capital Gains Tax is the main concern. A taxable disposal can arise when you sell for pounds, swap one token for another, spend crypto on goods or services or gift it to someone other than a spouse or civil partner. Many investors do not realise that swapping one token for another is a disposal in its own right, even where no money reaches a bank account. Other transactions, such as mining, staking and airdrops, can give rise to Income Tax. HMRC explains the basic rules in its guidance on the tax treatment of cryptoassets.
Records are the usual difficulty. Gains must be calculated transaction by transaction, using the pooling rules and the correct sterling values at each date. Investors who have used several wallets and platforms often find that the paperwork is incomplete. That is a problem to solve at the start of any disclosure, not a reason to delay.
The Three Ways a Crypto Tax Problem Gets Resolved
1. A voluntary disclosure before HMRC acts. This is generally the most favourable route. Penalties for an inaccuracy depend on the taxpayer’s behaviour and on whether disclosure is unprompted or prompted by HMRC. A disclosure made before HMRC has approached you is treated more generously, and where the failure was careless the penalty can be reduced significantly. Our guide to HMRC penalties sets out how the reductions are calculated.
2. A COP8 investigation. Code of Practice 8 applies where HMRC opens a civil investigation into a substantial amount of tax at risk, without alleging fraud. You are expected to cooperate, answer questions and produce records. HMRC can often obtain third party information and, where it has the evidence, can reach back beyond the ordinary four year limit. The outcome depends heavily on how HMRC characterises your behaviour.
3. A COP9 investigation. Code of Practice 9 is used where HMRC suspects tax fraud. HMRC offers a Contractual Disclosure Facility, and the taxpayer has 60 calendar days from the date of the letter to decide whether to accept. Accepting means making an outline disclosure within that window and a full disclosure afterwards, covering the tax, interest and penalties. In return, HMRC agrees not to investigate with a view to prosecution for the conduct disclosed. HMRC’s own guidance, on its Contractual Disclosure Facility page, strongly recommends independent advice before you respond. A COP9 letter is the most serious step in a civil tax case, and the 60 day period is short.
Time Limits: How Far Back Can HMRC Go?
The period HMRC can examine depends on the behaviour it can establish. In outline, the ordinary time limit for assessing a return is four years, extended to six years where the loss of tax was careless and to 20 years where it was deliberate. A longer period can apply to offshore matters. For crypto holdings in earlier tax years, this matters greatly, because a gain from the early years of the market could still be within reach if HMRC says the conduct was deliberate. Our guides to discovery assessments and to careless, deliberate or concealed behaviour explain the rules and how to challenge an assessment that is out of time. You can also read our longer piece on how to challenge HMRC discovery assessments.
What Should You Do If You Receive a Crypto Nudge Letter?
A nudge letter usually invites you to review your tax position and to make a disclosure within a stated period. It is important to avoid two common mistakes. The first is to ignore it, which can lead to a formal enquiry and a less favourable view of your behaviour. The second is to reply in haste with figures that are incomplete or wrong, which can create a fresh inaccuracy. In summary, a sensible approach is as follows:
- Do not delay. Note any date given in the letter and take advice before you respond.
- Gather your records. Collect exchange statements, wallet histories and bank records for every year concerned.
- Do not make partial admissions. Statements to HMRC can be used later, so they should be accurate and complete.
- Consider the route. A properly structured disclosure, a negotiated settlement or a defence to an overreaching assessment each call for a different strategy.
When HMRC Gets It Wrong
Not every crypto assessment is right. HMRC may value assets incorrectly, treat a transfer between your own wallets as a disposal, deny allowable costs or allege careless or deliberate conduct without evidence. Where there is a genuine dispute, you can appeal against the HMRC decision and, if necessary, take the case to the tribunal. Where you were misled by an adviser or platform about the tax position, there may also be a claim against them, which we explain in our guide to suing an adviser over bad HMRC advice. Time limits apply, as set out on our page on the limitation period for professional negligence claims.
How LEXLAW Can Help With a Crypto Tax Disclosure or Investigation
We act for individuals and businesses at every stage, from a first nudge letter to a full investigation, so you always have one team who knows your file:
- Privileged initial review. We assess your exposure, the years at risk and the likely behaviour category before anything is sent to HMRC.
- Choosing the right route. We advise whether to make a voluntary disclosure, how to respond to a COP8 or COP9 letter and whether a challenge is more appropriate.
- Managing the figures. We work with your records to reconstruct the position and test HMRC’s numbers.
- Negotiating the outcome. We engage with HMRC on penalties, time limits and payment arrangements, and where suitable we use alternative dispute resolution.
- Protecting your evidence. We prepare accurate witness evidence, as explained in our guidance on taxpayer witness statements.
- Appeals and tribunal advocacy. Where an agreed outcome is not possible, our barristers represent you. See our work on HMRC tax disputes.
- Second opinions. If you already have advisers, we can review their approach through our second opinion service.
Our fixed fee review starts from £1,750 plus VAT, and our funding options explain how longer cases can be financed. We do not offer legal aid.
Want legal advice from Tax Solicitors on your case?
Our simple enquiry form goes immediately to our tax litigators in Middle Temple, London. Call us on +442071830529 from 9am-6pm.
Information published on this page is for reference purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Figures are taken from information released by HMRC under the Freedom of Information Act and from public guidance, and may be updated. Please contact us for advice on your own circumstances.
